HoneyComb BEE

Headoffice Branch
27 14th Avenue, Northmead
 
Benoni, Gauteng
HoneyComb BEE Headoffice Logo

NEWS BLOG

Do current ESD practices work?

Do current ESD practices work?

23 November 2016 by HoneyComb BEE

The Enterprise and Supplier Development (ESD) element of the revised BBBEE Codes has made it clear that providing only financial and non-financial support to small suppliers and SMMEs is no longer sufficient.

Considering the imperative that the ESD element places on strategically engaging with suppliers, Christa Bonnet, founding member and Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of The Difference Makers, has found a worrying level of 'missing' knowledge among organisations and BEE specialists alike.

I have worked with well-known incubators, and accessed reports, proposals and presentations from various well-known incubators, ESD and supply chain consultants. From a strategic point of view, the following is lacking:

  • Lack of an in-depth understanding of how ESD fits into the supply chain.
  • Many organisations, consultants, specialists and practitioners try to plot enterprise development practices on supplier development, which cannot succeed sustainably if one does not understand strategic sourcing language and how ESD, as a consolidated construct, fits into total cost of ownership (TCO).
  • Lack of an in-depth understanding and capabilities of how to make ESD within the strategic sourcing and sustainability functions a return-on-investment (ROI), social return-on-investment (SROI) and sustainability imperative.
  • Lack of an in-depth understanding of how to mine the value chain within the organisation and the value chain of its stakeholders (both internal and external) in alignment with these imperatives
  • Lack of an integrated approach illustrating the compound impact of access to market for SMMEs and bigger suppliers through an integrated value chain approach.

Some of the pitfalls in terms of current ESD practices include it being largely scorecard-driven by companies who have been hit hard by the Amended Codes; having a focus on form over substance; and a lack of strategic intent or alignment with the core business strategies.

The latter leads in many cases to ESD being seen as a challenge or burden to the organisation from a holistic view-point, and in the process is disposed of or outsourced in the least disruptive manner to the core business.

In order to present a sustainable solution, some of the skills needed to implement ESD differently are critical thinking, curiosity, systems thinking and an understanding of results-based accounting, project management and strategic sourcing methodologies.

Having had discussions with CPOs, ESD practitioners, consultants, incubators, agents and SMMEs, the same approach and solutions (with a differentiator here and there) are found across the ESD industry.

Ask the difficult questions

If we remove the fluff and glitter from the current programmes and solutions, two questions arise:

  • Of the millions that are allocated to these projects, how much actually reaches the SMMEs and is used to their benefit?
  • What are the sustainable impacts of the money spent, measured on a ROI and SROI level?

I have seen some of the answers myself. Sadly, once the superficial answers have been tested and removed - what comes out as true benefits to the intended beneficiaries are not always a pretty picture.

They are important questions and they must be answered in terms of outcomes - but the answers will most likely not to be liked by some who do not understand the workings of RBA and SROI methodologies in terms of ESD and sustainability.

Audit

I always recommend an independent SROI audit prior to making such strategic decisions and on an annual ongoing basis to ensure that the majority of the funds spent are for the the benefit of the intended SMMEs and not third party service providers.

When silo thinking has been shifted to an integrated approach between all business imperatives then the path from "as is" to the "to be" becomes a practical reality. Then a paradigm shift takes place on a fundamental level to leapfrog from compliance into a sustainable and wired business thinking to ensure a sustainable transformation of the supplier base.

In closing, some critical imperatives that must be taken into consideration as change drivers include management support, sufficient capacity and capabilities in the team driving the ESD focus within supply chain, bespoke levels of internal and external stakeholder communication, efficient and supportive processes and systems, monitoring and evaluation, business partnerships and funding mechanisms. 


10 questions to help you initiate and integrate a successful ESD strategy
23 November 2016

10 questions to help you initiate and integrate a successful ESD strategy

by HoneyComb BEE
Under the old BEE Codes, enterprise development was the most neglected element, followed closely by preferential procurement. The Amended Codes of Good Practice brings together preferential procurement, supplier development and enterprise development into one priority element, forcing organisations...

REVIEWS

START YOUR REVIEW OF HoneyComb BEE
First, your rating here
 
Your review here

PHOTO GALLERY

ABOUT US

Honeycomb BEE Ratings is a member of the Association of BEE Professionals (ABP). The ABP is an independent national Membership Organisation established to lead the Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) Verification Industry as it takes up a vital role in the transformation of the South African economy.

Honeycomb BEE Ratings is a SANAS ACCREDITED BEE VERIFICATION AGENCY and has held their Accreditation since 2007.

View our Certificate of Accreditation:

  • Accredited Sectors
  • BBBEE Amended Codes of Good Practice
  • Tourism
  • Information and Communication Technology (ICT)
  • Property
  • Financial
  • Forest
  • Agri
  • Marketing and Communications (MAC)
  • Transport

SERVICES

BEE Ratings

On-Site Document Verification

A Broad-Based rating is an in-depth process and an On-Site Verification of the evidence submitted for each one of the elements is required in order to achieve the maximum amount of points possible.The end result of this process is a B-BBEE Verification Certificate issued by Honeycomb that can then also be used by the measured entity when tendering for government business or for other procurement purposes.

Pre-Rating Assessment

A pre-rating assessment is conducted on all of the evidence provided by you, and is verified by Honeycomb through an On-Site Verification. The result of this exercise is a B-BBEE scorecard, indicating the points received for each element as well as the B-BBEE Contribution status.

Rating Preparation

Collation of Documents and Information

The collation of evidence that supports your BEE score is essential, since the rating process is based on the evidence submitted. Our collation service team will assist in collating the proper evidence that is required for your BEE rating.

Impartiality Policy

1. Policy Statement

  • We shall ensure that our shareholders, directors, management and all internal personnel understand and, by way of legally enforceable agreements whichbinds  them to our Code of Conduct, are committed to
  • The principles and mechanisms designed to implement and verify all seven          elements of Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment, with particular            emphasis on:
  • Objectivity;
  • Independence;
  • The disclosure of conflicts of interest and any other commercial, financial or other pressures which might pose a threat to their impartiality;
  • Lack of bias and prejudice and the maintenance of neutrality;
  • Conducting BEE verification exercises fairly and openly, with detachment and balance, in line with recommended best practices set by the industry.
  • The composition, terms of reference, duties, authorities and responsibilities of our analysts and verification managers shall be formally documented and shall be authorized by the Managing Director.
  • All personnel shall have access to the information necessary for them to perform their duties and functions. Access to information will be regulated by the Managing Director to ensure the confidentiality of clients and the impartiality of our personnel.
  • Our personnel shall be recruited in order to represent a balance of interests so that no single interest predominates.
  • We undertake not to allow any consultancy body from stating or implying that the ratings service provided by Honeycomb is simpler, faster or less expensive than any of its competitors nor will we state or imply that, if a particular consultancy is used, a BEE verification would be simpler, faster or less expensive.
  • Honeycomb will not provide both BEE verification and BEE consultancy services to the same measured entity, unless a period of two years has elapsed  following the end of such a BBBEE consultancy.

2. Reference

R47-02 Clauses 10.2.2, 10.2.3, 12.2 and 13.6

Procedure – HR/MPPR0/001

SPECIALS

EVENTS

DOCUMENTS

MEET THE TEAM